Need help with negative proportions in experiment
Hello! I got referred to here by someone from the econometrics subreddit.
I ran an experiment with a treatment and a control group. Treatment group voted under an electoral rule, where voters could cast a negative vote (with a score of -1) and a positive vote (+1). Control group used the standard First-Past-The-Post rule.
I want to compare the results of extreme parties (I know which those are) and see if the difference is significant. However, these extreme parties obtained a negative result, so a normal test of proportion doesn't work. What do I do?
Answer
- The questioner was satisfied with and accepted the answer, or
- The answer was evaluated as being 100% correct by the judge.
-
Hey Kav10, Thank you very much for your answer. I will look into the first option, but in the meantime, please clarify something for your second suggestion. If I add a constant to the negative votes, should I not add the same constant to all parties? And once I do, what kind of statistical test should I use to determine whether the difference is significantly different from zero?
-
Yes, you should apply the same constant to all parties consistently. This ensures that you're comparing the parties' performance on a common scale. Since you're interested in comparing the differences between two groups (treatment and control), you can use a t-test for paired samples.
-
-
I thought t-tests were only used to compare means. However, I want to compare sums here, not means.
-
That’s right. For comparing sums, you can use the Wilcoxon test I explained above.
-
-
My apologies, but then I don’t understand. So how do I use the t-test after adding a constant?
-
Not the t-test. The Wilcoxon Test.
-
-
In that case, what is the difference between the two approaches you suggested? I’ll have to use a non-parametric test on both occasions.
- answered
- 764 views
- $5.00
Related Questions
- applied probability
- Statistics for argumentative data and politics
- Describing Bayes Theorem succinctly in words
- Sample size calculation - single mean method
- Explain how the mean of discrete variables is $\mu = \sum[x P(x)]$
- Operations research
- Dice expected value question
- How to simplify this expression? (statistics)